Maryland Workers’ Comp IME: What to Expect at an Independent Medical Examination

Maryland Workers’ Comp IME: The Complete Guide for Injured Workers

Quick Answer: In Maryland, an Independent Medical Examination (IME) is a medical exam requested and paid for by the workers’ compensation insurance company. The doctor performing your IME is not your treating physician — they are hired by the insurer to evaluate your injury, and their report will almost always be used to minimize or deny your benefits. Knowing exactly what to expect before you walk into that exam room can be the difference between protecting your claim and losing it.

From Shane: The Hard Truth About IMEs in Maryland

I remember sitting in the waiting room for my IME thinking it was just another doctor’s appointment. It wasn’t. The physician barely touched me — the exam lasted eleven minutes. Then months later, I saw the report: it claimed I had “full range of motion” and was capable of returning to full-duty work. None of that matched my reality. I didn’t know I had rights. I didn’t know I could bring someone with me. I didn’t know I should have documented every second of that appointment.

That experience is why this page exists. Maryland’s IME process is legal, but it is not neutral. Walk in prepared or walk in at a serious disadvantage. There is no middle ground.

What Is a Workers’ Comp IME in Maryland?

Under Maryland Code, Labor and Employment § 9-722, an insurer or employer has the right to request that a claimant submit to a medical examination by a physician of the insurer’s choosing. This examination is used to challenge your treating doctor’s conclusions about your diagnosis, work restrictions, impairment rating, or need for ongoing treatment.

The term “independent” is misleading. These physicians are routinely retained by insurance companies and defense attorneys. A 2022 investigation by the Workers Injury Law & Advocacy Group (WILG) found that IME physicians hired by insurers sided with the insurer in approximately 60–70% of cases nationally — a figure consistent with Maryland practitioners who represent injured workers.

Step-by-Step: The Maryland IME Process

Step 1: You Receive Written Notice of the IME

The insurer must provide you with reasonable written notice of the examination date, time, location, and the name of the examining physician. Under Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission practice, “reasonable” is generally interpreted as at least seven days’ notice, though attorneys routinely negotiate for more.

What to do immediately:
– Write down the date you received notice.
– Research the IME doctor. Search their name + “IME” + “plaintiff” or “defense.” Look for published depositions or testimonies. Prolific defense IME doctors leave paper trails.
– Contact your attorney, if you have one, before confirming attendance.

Step 2: Review What the Doctor Has Been Given

The insurer will send the IME physician your medical records — but they choose which records to send. Your attorney can demand disclosure of what was submitted. Missing records that show the severity of your injury are not an accident.

Step 3: Prepare Physically and Strategically

  • Bring someone with you. Maryland does not explicitly prohibit a companion from accompanying you into the exam room. Bring your spouse, a trusted friend, or a patient advocate. Their presence creates a witness.
  • Do not volunteer information. Answer questions honestly, but answer only what is asked. Do not discuss your hobbies, weekend activities, or physical capabilities beyond what is directly relevant to the injury.
  • Document your symptoms that day. If you’re having a bad pain day, note it. If travel to the exam aggravates your condition, document that too.

Step 4: The Physical Examination

The exam typically lasts 10–45 minutes — often significantly shorter than your regular appointments with your treating physician. The doctor will review your history, conduct a physical examination, and may ask questions about your job duties and daily activities.

Critical: Note the exact start and end time of your examination. Short exam times are frequently challenged in hearings.

Step 5: The IME Report Is Generated

Within 30 days (typically), the physician produces a written report. This report is sent to the insurer, not to you automatically. Your attorney can and should obtain a copy. The report will address:
– Causal relationship between your injury and the work incident
– Current diagnosis and prognosis
– Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI) status
– Permanent partial disability (impairment) rating
– Ability to return to work (full duty, light duty, or restricted)
– Need for further medical treatment

Step 6: The Report Is Used at a Workers’ Compensation Commission Hearing

If the insurer uses the IME report to modify or terminate your benefits, the matter goes before the Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission (MWCC). Your treating physician’s opinion will be weighed against the IME physician’s opinion. The Commissioner decides which opinion is more credible.

What the Law Says vs. What Actually Happens

Issue What the Law Says What Actually Happens
Exam notice Reasonable written notice required Notices sometimes arrive late or to wrong address — delaying your prep time
Exam scope Limited to the claimed injury IME doctors frequently probe unrelated pre-existing conditions to apportion blame
Record completeness Full medical file implied Insurers selectively omit records that support the severity of your injury
IME physician objectivity “Independent” by name Many IME doctors in Maryland derive 30–80% of their income from insurer referrals
Your right to your own IME You may obtain one Your “IME” is called an AME (medical evaluation) and carries equal legal weight — but it costs money

Real Case Example: What Happened to David K.

David, a 44-year-old warehouse supervisor in Baltimore County, tore his rotator cuff unloading freight in 2023. His orthopedic surgeon recommended surgical repair and estimated a 6-month recovery with permanent partial restrictions.

Six weeks after surgery, the insurer scheduled an IME with an orthopedic physician in Rockville. David didn’t know he could bring someone with him. He went alone. The exam lasted 14 minutes. The physician asked him to raise his arm, documented “functional range of motion,” and issued a report concluding David had reached MMI and could return to full-duty work.

David’s benefits were immediately modified. His attorney obtained the IME doctor’s deposition records from two prior cases and discovered the physician had issued nearly identical reports — “full range of motion,” “return to full duty” — in 11 of the last 14 cases reviewed. At the MWCC hearing, David’s surgeon testified in person. The Commissioner found the treating physician’s opinion more credible, restored full benefits, and approved the surgery follow-up treatment.

The outcome was correct — but it took eight months and significant legal fees to get there. Preparation before the IME would have been cheaper and less stressful.

5 Critical Mistakes to Avoid at Your Maryland IME

  1. Going in blind. Research the doctor. Search Maryland Case Search for prior testimony. Ask your attorney if this physician is known to the defense bar. Knowledge is protection.

  2. Oversharing. IME doctors are trained to ask open-ended questions. “How’s your day-to-day life been?” is not small talk. Every answer you give is fair game for the report.

  3. Inconsistency with your prior records. If your records say you can’t lift over 5 pounds, don’t demonstrate lifting the doctor’s heavy medical bag out of courtesy. Minor physical inconsistencies are weaponized.

  4. Failing to document the exam duration. If the exam lasted 9 minutes and your treating physician sees you for an hour each visit, that discrepancy matters at a hearing. Write it down the moment you leave.

  5. Not obtaining the IME report promptly. Your attorney should request the report immediately. The insurer is not required to send it to you automatically. Delays in getting the report mean delays in challenging it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I refuse to attend an IME in Maryland?

Direct Answer: No. Refusal to attend an IME in Maryland can result in suspension of your workers’ compensation benefits.

Under Maryland Code, Labor and Employment § 9-722, submission to a reasonable medical examination is a condition of receiving benefits. If you refuse or fail to attend without good cause, the Workers’ Compensation Commission has the authority to suspend your indemnity benefits until you comply. “Good cause” for non-attendance includes inadequate notice, a scheduling conflict with a legitimate medical appointment, or physical inability to travel to the location on that specific date. If you have any conflict, contact your attorney immediately — do not simply no-show. Strategic rescheduling based on documented cause is very different from a flat refusal. One can be justified; the other will hurt your claim.

Q: Does the IME doctor have to be licensed in Maryland?

Direct Answer: Yes. The examining physician must hold a valid Maryland medical license.

While the statute does not specify specialty requirements, the examining physician should generally hold credentials relevant to your claimed injury. An insurer scheduling a general practitioner to evaluate a complex spinal injury, for example, can be challenged. Your attorney can object to the qualifications of the appointed physician before the exam takes place. Always verify the physician’s active license status through the Maryland Board of Physicians license lookup tool at mbp.state.md.us before attending. A lapsed or disciplinary record on a license is immediately relevant to the physician’s credibility at a hearing.

Q: Can I record the IME in Maryland?

Direct Answer: Maryland is a two-party consent state for audio recordings, which complicates covert recording — but bringing a witness is your most effective practical tool.

Under Maryland Courts and Judicial Proceedings § 10-402, recording a private conversation without consent of all parties is illegal. However, you can ask the IME physician for consent to record — they will almost certainly refuse, but the refusal itself is notable. The practical alternative is to bring a witness. A companion who is present during the exam can provide a contemporaneous account of what occurred, how long the exam lasted, what questions were asked, and whether the physician appeared to conduct a thorough evaluation. Your witness can also take notes in the waiting room immediately after the exam concludes.

Q: What if the IME doctor’s findings are completely wrong?

Direct Answer: You have the right to challenge the IME report with your own medical expert’s testimony before the Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission.

The IME report is not the final word — it is one piece of evidence. Your treating physician’s opinion carries significant weight, especially if they have treated you over an extended period and have documented objective findings such as imaging, surgical records, or functional capacity evaluations. Maryland Commissioners are experienced in evaluating competing medical opinions. The factors they weigh include: length of the treating relationship, consistency of the medical opinion with objective evidence, credentials of the physician, and yes — the documented brevity of an IME exam versus the depth of treating care. A strong treating physician who testifies clearly and consistently almost always outweighs a brief IME report.

Q: How does an IME affect my permanent disability rating in Maryland?

Direct Answer: An IME physician’s impairment rating directly influences how much permanent disability compensation you may receive — making this one of the highest-stakes parts of the entire process.

Maryland uses the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (most recently the 6th edition) to calculate permanent partial disability awards. The percentage rating assigned by the IME doctor will be compared against your treating physician’s rating. Even a 5–10% difference in impairment rating can translate to thousands of dollars in compensation. For example, under Maryland’s current workers’ comp rates, a 10% difference in a permanent partial disability rating for a serious back injury could represent $15,000–$30,000 or more depending on the body part and wage history. This is precisely why insurers invest in IME physicians who trend toward lower ratings.

Q: What is the statute of limitations for filing a workers’ comp claim in Maryland?

Direct Answer: In Maryland, you have 2 years from the date of the accidental injury or the date of disablement to file a workers’ compensation claim.

Missing this deadline almost always bars your claim permanently, regardless of how serious your injury is. This makes timing your response to an IME report critical — if the report is used to deny your claim and you are approaching the 2-year window, you must act immediately. File your claim with the Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission before that deadline, even if negotiations are ongoing. Filing preserves your rights; it does not force you into litigation. An attorney can help you file protectively while continuing to pursue a settlement or voluntary agreement with the insurer.

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. I am not a lawyer. Consult a licensed workers’ compensation attorney in Maryland before making any decisions about your claim.

Maryland Workers’ Compensation Commission
10 East Baltimore Street, Baltimore, MD 21202
Phone: (410) 864-5100 | wcc.state.md.us

More Maryland Workers Comp Resources

See Also

Need help finding the right next step?

This article is general educational information, not personal advice. You can use our Contact and Feedback page to report a correction, suggest a topic, or—where available—optionally request a connection with an independent professional.